top of page
Search

So Adobe got cloned... but is it a good thing?

Writer: Dillon Osborne
Dillon Osborne
Oct 25
6 min read

Let's take a look at this whole creative/software relationship and think about it a bit more.... I've had a long relationship with Adobe products. My dad got me working in Pagemaker 6 and Photoshop 5 in the late 1990's. I used to create PDF presentations for school and college with early editions of InDesign becasue we never owned a Windows computer with Microsoft office. Macintosh from the get go... But a company named Artcraft have just cloned the entire suite and offered it for free online...

Now, my Adobe relationship normally went like this - we pay for software - they supplied it on hard copy. We own that copy for as long as we want. Then CC came along moving it all to the cloud, with a subscription model that was disguised as convenience ...and for the most part it is pretty convenient. But they had us by the short and curlys. I use the full suite. Design, Illustration, Photo, Video, Audio, PDF. Some for work some for fun, some for life admin. But I'm invested, it's how I do things, I have spent years learning the software, mastering the speed, the tricks, the shortcuts. So each time they raise the price I have no option but to pay it. Begrudgingly I pay it. Every year a new price. No real reward for being a loyal customer. The way around it was to cancel a subscription that would prompt them to discount it by 50%. Which always begs the question that if you are willing to discount it when I threaten to leave, why don't you just be decent and offer me a loyalty discount? Eventually Adobe caught wind, updated everyones subscriptions and sort of tricked us into agreeing and signing up to a fresh 12 month contract with insane cancelation fees. I used to pay the rolling month contract, cancel anytime, they just chaneged it one day to a 12 month contract disguised as a simple "policy update" ... I'm the muppet for clicking agree cos who reads the T&Cs in something like this? So here we are. I pay the full price every month. I started looking into other options, like Affinity which is decent but some weird things in it, I looked at Photomator and Pixelmator which are also decent. I already edit video in FCPX so Premier isnt a problem... but each time I came back to the sentence "It's not quite Adobe". Lets face it the software is great, they have spent years developing it, working directly with creatives in all sorts of industries, learning, building, reiterating. Its sort of a collaboration between the people who build it and the people who use it. Driven by things like the Adobe user forums where we all help each other. But somewhere along the line Adobe forgot about their users. The Designers, Photographers, Filmmakers, Illustrators who gave them a business worth pursuing. This is where the AI bubble floated into the Adobe world with the things like Firefly and straight up they ran a campaign about bypassing the photoshoot and jumping to end product by generating an image with their AI Model. How can they promote skipping the Photoshoot? The Photographer? The people behind capturing these ideas. It starts here but ends with them saying "skip the illustrator, skip the designer, skip the editor.... just generate it all with AI" - Then what's the point in any of it? Soulless, computer generated, theft really. I'm not against AI so to speak, I feel it has its uses. I also feel like its been around for a lot longer than we know, it's just been branded differently and released at scale. I think it helps with industrial progress and medical progress... places where we need streamline procedures, faster solutions and be able to test, make repeat at scale. But the art world? the creative world? are different. We don't need it to be streamelined The craft by humans is what makes it special. Adobe in my opinion, put that to the side to join the race. Adobe forgot about their true loyal customers who have payed to use their software and helped them develop it over the years in favour of getting "generation" into the hands of millions of people who have no business creating art. Their mistake was thinking they were untouchable. Fast forward a few years to early October. A company called Artcraft hit the headlines with their release of an "Adobe Clone". I first caught wind of it hours after it was posted on Desginweek with and article written by David Coveney explaining the whole situation. I had never heard of this company prior to this but immediatly caught my eye. I was intrigued...

Within minutes I had downloaded it all super fast and easy. All individual apps straight to the desktop. l Opened them one by one and was so impressed. it felt familiar, worked the same apart from a few snags that are expected considering it's just been released. But it was mad that someoen can just reverse engineer and effecitivly vibe code the Adobe suite like this. There has to be a catch at some point, Artcraft offer AI tool subscription so I image they will give the software for free but encourage you to sign up to their AI stuff to get those features in the software at some point.

A week after its launch I already see they have changed it to download their own launcher to download apps and allow updates as and when they come out. This is similar to the Adobe Creative Cloud app. So they are already setting it up for a potential paywall.. or maybe the powers that be have more sway than we think.

One concern I have is around security. their apps are open source code and they are hosted on Github allowing for fast development and updates because of the colaborative approach to building the backend code, but do we really know what we are downloading and installing? Adobe is a well established and trusted company... i mean... as trusted as much as we know lol when I was younger I was told don't download and install stuff, don't access terminal for anything... and now its fair game. But heres the thing... this whole race for AI development is potentially coming back around to bite the people peddling it in the ass and this feels like the first noticeable one. There are people are using AI in some incredible ways and promoting it online showing what they do and how they use it... saying things like "If you aren't using it you will be left behind" But these people are acting like, as long as they embrace and use it, then they are untouchable. I'm not sure if this is always an educated informed decision rather than a knee jerk panic not to be "left behind" the same way we all jump onto a new social media platform when its released in fear of missing out on the next big thing. Remember Vero? What a load of dribble. Anyway... AI is a bit like that in my opinion. I think that is what Adobe have done... pushed on incorporating AI into their apps promoting 'creation without the creative people.' Allowing "Anyone to be creative" because as long as they are the ones pushing it they are ok... and then we get to this point... where "the people fight back" so to speak... and by fight back I mean just copy their entire product line and release it for free. There are no rules against all this shit, no one is really policing it. But that was all fine apparently when we were stomping on the people at the bottom... this is now a huge corporation being ripped off. What happens now? will we see rules brought in to defend big business? Adobe decide to set sail on HMS AI enroute they burn the bridge with their creatives, thinking AI will look afetr them because they are adopting and embracing it. Only for AI to sneak into their IP, ravish them, steal all their shit, give them the finger and push them into the sea to fend for themselves with no support lol now here we all are swimming about with no idea what we're all doing... looking at Adobe like "Lads! WTF happened?"


Anyway... I just think this has been a great example of the race to the bottom. Everyone trying to beat everyone to some finish line that doesn't exist... it's just a treadmill that wears us all out slowely and leaves us for dead along the way. I think we all just need to take a breath and think about that saying "just because it can be done doesn't mean it should be done." I'm not sure where my mind sits with AI, it is useful in some ways and horrible in others. Downloading and using this new software is 2 fingers up to Adobe yes, but simultaneously jumping on the AI boat the same way they have done is part of the problem. I'd ratrher Adobe were reasonable with the prices, didn't steal all our work to feed their AI and looked after their community, then We just continue to pay them forever lol but also give us an option to "freeze our software" at a certain point, pay no more, get no more updates. Thats more for people who have gone as far as they will with their computers and tech... think 70 year designer who is happy where he is... I mean, how do any of us really know what to do any more...I guess we all justify it in different ways and I don't have an answer to this question yet...


This is just where my brain has been recently... Dil

 
 
 

Comments


© Dillon Osborne - Straight Up Creative

bottom of page